HMONG

LUB UNIVERSITY OF

Sydney

Susan Hayes AO PhD FIASSID
Xib fwb ntawm Behavioural Sciences hauv tshuaj

Saib mob lub hlwb Txoj Kev Soj Ntsuam

NTAWM

Alexander BAILIFF

DOB m 25 Lub yim hli ntuj 1970

HNUB TIM 0F Txoj Kev Soj Ntsuam - 11 RAU HLI 2013

Npaj BY Susan HAYES, AO, PhD

Xib fwb NTAWM BEHAVIOURAL Sciences HAUV tshuaj

DEPARTMENT OF tshuaj

UNIVERSITY 0F Sydney NSW 2006

Behavioural Sciences hauv tshuaj T +61 2 9551 2776 Aam15211515 454
Sydney Kho Mob Tsev Kawm Ntawv F +61 2 9551 5519 CRICOS GOOQSA
Blackburn Building U06 E Susan.hayes @ sydneyßduau

University of Sydney sydney.edu.au

Saib mob lub hlwb Txoj Kev Soj Ntsuam
0F
Alexander BAILIFF
DOB - 25 Lub yim hli ntuj 197 ()
HNUB TIM 0F Txoj Kev Soj Ntsuam - 11 RAU HLI 2013

Background

On 11 Lub rau hli ntuj 2013, koj Alexander Bailiff kawm kuv chav nyob rau hauv lub University of Sydney rau
lub hom phiaj ntawm undertaking ib tug saib mob lub hlwb kev ntsuam xyuas nyob rau hauv relation mus rau criminal
Plaub nyob rau hauv Tshiab South Wales Hauv Zos Tsev Hais Plaub. Kuv paub hais tias koj Bailiff yog them Nrog
tawg thiab uas nkag mus rau ib tug dweliing lub tsev ua ib tug loj heev indictabie ua txhaum (vaj tse
kev puas tsuaj). Tsis tas li ntawd, nyob rau hauv thaum ntxov Lub kaum hli ntuj 2012 koj Bailiff xa ib co xov mus rau ib tug
yav tas los tus khub, ib co uas muaj tau suicidal ideation. Nws them nyob rau hauv
ACT nrog contraveníng ib tug tiv thaiv Order thiab tus nqi uas tau teev rau ua ntej lub ACT
Magistrates tsev hais plaub txiav txim rau nyob rau hauv lub yim hli ntuj 2013.

Nyob rau hauv kev npaj daim ntawv qhia no 1 twb muaj kuv ib tug hnav ntawm cov ntaub ntawv nrog rau cov Tsev Hais Plaub
Kev tuaj kawm ntawv daim Ntawv Ceeb Toom thiab Tub Ceev Xwm QHOV TSEEB Sheet hais txog tej xwm txheej on ll Lub peb hlis ntuj 2013; ib daim qauv ntawm
Criminal Keeb kwm ntawm koj Bailiff; nqi thiab cov nqe lus ntawm qhov tseeb nyob rau hauv relation mus rau txheej xwm nyob rau hauv
Lub kaum hli ntuj 2012, thaum yav tas los tus khub tau txais sorne xov; saib mob sau los ntawm
None ntawm Wales Tsev Kho Mob Kiloh Centre; thiab keeb kwm qhia sib tam los ntawm 2003 mus rau 2012.

Kuv tau nug kom Sau ntawv rau ib daim ntawv qhia rau forensic siv nyob rau hauv lub tsev hais plaub lub qhov foìlowíng teeb meem:

l mob ntawm tej yam kev puas hlwb, kev mob los yog kev loj hlob kev tsis taus uas koj Bailiff
suffers los ntawm tam sim no thiab thaum lub sij hawm ntawm lub liam ua txhaum on l 1 Lub peb hlis ntuj 2013;

2 Nyob rau hauv saib taus ntawm tej yam mob ua, cov ntsiab lus ntawm koj Bailiffs tam sim no tsoom fwv kev kho mob (yog hais tias

alfly);

3 tswv yim pom zoo 0n tej kev kho mob rau yav tom ntej tsoom fwv los yog kev them nyiaj yug lub hom phiaj, nrog rau ib qho

lub tswv yim on Seb thov txoj kev kho mob yog muaj nyob rau hauv kev puas hlwb noj qab haus huv los yog chaw
los ntawm mental health kev pab nyob rau hauv NSW los yog ACT, thiab

4 kev pom zoo nyob rau degree ntawm kev saib xyuas los yog saib xyuas yuav tsum tau nyob rau hauv tej yam
npaj siab kev kho mob los sis tsoom fwv kev pab txhawb nqa lub hom phiaj thiab muaj xws li kev saib xyuas
tsis pub dhau NSW los yog ACT.

Tsis tas li ntawd, kuv tau raug hais kom qhia ib lub tswv yim raws li seb tus neeg yog los plead
nyob rau hauv lub Presser cov txheej xwm.

Yuav kom raws li uas nws ua tau, kuv tsis canvass 'qhov kev tshwm sim ntawm tus txhaum nrog koj
Baiìiff, raws li tau thov.

Kws NEEG UA POV THAWJ Statement

Kuv lees paub tias kuv tau txais thiab nyeem ib Copy ntawm Uniform Civil Kev ua kom raws cai
2005, Schedule 7, kws NEEG UA POV THAWJ cai, thiab kuv pom zoo yuav ki uake los ntawm nws. Kuv muaj
degrees ntawm BA (Hons Kuv) thiab PhD los ntawm lub tsev kawm ntawv ntawm Psychology nyob rau hauv lub University of Tshiab
Sab qab teb Wales. Kuv yog ib tug kws soj ntaum tib sau npe nyob rau hauv teb chaws Australia thiab ib tug tswv cuab ntawm Australian
Lub hlwb Society thiab nws cov College ntawm Forensic Psychologists `Kuv yog ib tug khub ntawm
International Association rau scientific kev soj ntsuam no ntawm kev txawj ntse Xiam Oob Qhab thiab ib tug tswv cuab ofthe
Australasian Society rau qhov kev soj ntsuam ntawm cov kev txawj ntse Disability. Kuv tau pom zoo ua saib mob thiab
kev tshawb fawb Ua Hauj Lwm nyob rau hauv forensic psychology rau ntau tshaj ob decades; Kuv tau luam tawm ntau tshaj
2 () cov phau ntawv los yog phau ntawv tshooj, thiab ntau tshaj 64 cov ntaub ntawv nyob rau hauv phau ntawv kws nyob rau hauv kuv ñelds ntawm
txawj nyob rau hauv psychology `Nyob rau hauv qhov teeb meem no neeg kuv hais kom qhia on mentaì lub xeev, ib tug
 nyob rau hauv uas kuv kws. Kuv npaj qhia nyob rau hauv conformity nrog kws NEEG UA POV THAWJ Code
ntawm coj nyob.

Tsev neeg thiab cov Social Keeb kwm

Thaum lub sij hawm ntawm qhov kev ntsuam xyuas, koj Baiìiff mas hnub nyoog 42 xyoos, ib tug txiv neej Leej twg nyhav dhau heev lawm mas
inappropriately hnav khaub ncaws rau huab cua (nws yog nyob rau hauv luv thiab ib lub tsho Tee on ib tug khaub thuas caij ntuj no hnub);
nws hnav spectacles thiab tau ob peb hnub 'kev loj hlob ntawm stubble, thiab ib lub cev muaj zog tsw. Nws
hnav ib basebalì cap thoob plaws hauv kev ntsuam xyuas.

Koj Bailifŕs cai thiab demeanor mas tsis tsim nyog. Nws tshaj-me ntsis txog cov neeg
uas dhau los ntawm nyob rau hauv qhov corridor, thiab ntaus ib tug ofñce ntawm ib tug npog yaig rau tib pem teb rau ib tug
sib tham. Nws tsis tshua muaj nyuaj rau kev sib tham vim hais tias nws nyob rau hauv nws tangential
cov lus teb thiab tshaj-ìncìusìve.

Keeb kwm hais tias twb tau mas tsis tshua muaj fragmented. Koj Bailiff sai li sai tau paub txog
kuv hais tias nws tus cwj pwm mas disinhibited tshuav nqi rau lub fact tias nws txom nyem los ntawm kev puas tsuaj rau lub hlwb
tsim tawm nyob rau hauv ib lub tsheb huam yuaj thaum nws hais txog 15. Nws npaj (nyob rau hauv kuv lub tswv yim
txhob txwm) mus tso rau neeg siab tus cwj pwm uas twb tau piav rau ib yam ntawm cov ntaub ntawv
muaj rau kuv, Thaj ib daim ntawv sau los ntawm koj Roger Parker QC, muaj cai Adducing Pov thawj mus
Ua pov thawj los yog Dfsprove paj hlwb Puas (paj hlwb Puas Medico-Raws li txoj cai yam, Blackwell xovxwm,
Sydney (1994)). Qhov no yog hais txog to Work los ntawm Dr William Lishman. Yuav kom Quote briefly ntawm no

page:

"Feem ntau cov yam ntxwv (ntawm focal cerebral teeb meem no) yog o disinhibition nrog expansive tshaj
familiarity, tactlessness, tshaj tolkativeness, childish siab los yog pronkish thiab panning
kev sib raug zoo thiab raug cai tswj tej zaum yuav raug diminished nrog tsis muaj kev txhawj xeeb rau yav tom ntej no thiab rau qhov
txim ntawm kev ua (sic). . . tshuaj ntsuam ntawm Mood yog feem ntau pom, uas yog ib qho kev npliag thiab
nrov euphoria es tsis yog ib tug trae elation uas communicates mus rau saib. . .
concentration, mloog thiab muaj peev xwm mus nqa tawm ib lub tswv yim npaj kho kev ua si yog los ntawm cov impaired
hloov tiam sis zoo rau cov kev xeem ntawm formal txawj ntse yog feem ntau ceeb zoo khaws cai

ib zaug lub parienf tus txoj kev koom tes tau nyab xeeb.

Raws li qhia, nws ciali hais tias koj Bailiff twb sim sab laj txog yam no piav txog.

Koj Baiiiff qhia kuv hais tias nws twb heen bom ntawm lub Royal Tsev Kho Mob rau cov poj niam thiab mas yim
lub lis piam premature vim nws niam yog nyob rau hauv kev nyuaj siab nyob rau hauv lub sij hawm. Nws yog ib tug viv ncaus, Vanessa,

uas yog laus dua tshaj nws thiab nws twb tua thaum lub sij hawm lub tsheb huam yuaj nyob rau hauv uas koj Bailiff twb
muab kev koom tes thaum nws hnub nyoog I5. Nws muaj ib tug kwv tij uas yog 11 xyoo yau dua nws yog. Nws hais tias
hais tias nws cov niam txiv ntuj sib cais los ntawm lub sij hawm uas nws 10, ua ntej mus rau tij laug raug yug.
Nws khaws cia hais tias nws niam yog ib tug ntau ntawm prescribed noj tshuaj thaum nws cov tub ntxhais hluas
thiab hais tias nws bashed ob himsehC thiab nws laus dua muam. Nws thov tias leej niam twb tsav tsheb
lub oar uas tshwm sim los ntawm kev tuag ofthe muam thiab nws lub hlwb raug mob. Nws hais tias nyob rau lub hnub nyoog ntawm 15
tom qab qhov kev huam yuaj nws raug xa mus rau ib tug xov tooj ntawm cov refuges los ntawm nws niam.

Koj mus kawm ib tug xov tooj ntawm cov tsev kawm ntawv nyob rau hauv Victoria txog thaum lub sij hawm uas nws muam twb tua
thiab nws raug mob. Cov tsev neeg pib mus nyob hauv cov Glen IRIS kom txog rau thaum nws hais txog peb lub xyoos ntawm
muaj hnub nyoog thiab ces nyob rau hauv Healesville. Nws piav txog nws lub neej raws li ua traumatic vim lub tsheb
kev huam yuaj. Nyob rau ntawm ib theem nws yog nyob rau hauv None Henry Tsev Kho Mob rau Rehabilitation. Nws mus t0
Canberra thiab nyob nrog nws ntuj leej txiv. Nws nyob hauv Melbourne nrog ib tug hluas nkauj. Rau
hais txog cov xeem xyoo nws tau nyob atan qhov chaw nyob rau hauv Narrabundah los ntawm nws tus kheej.

Nws siv ib tug zoo deal ntawm lub sij hawm sim los tham txog lub tsheb huam yuaj thiab kuj yog kev sib raug zoo
nrog nws tus qub hluas nkauj uas yog muab kev koom tes nyob rau hauv lub Apprehended nruj ua tsiv Order tias nws
breached by xa nws xov. Koj twb dua kom rov qab mus rau lub
lo lus nug uas nug thiab raws li txoj kev no txuas ntxiv nws lub uas nws paub irritated
los ntawm qhov tseeb hais tias nws tsis sanctioned mus hais lus nyob rau hauv ntev hais txog cov teeb meem hais txog cov uas nws
xav los tham txog. Txawm tias muaj dua qhia koj Bailiff tias kuv tau nug kom tsis txhob
canvass qhov kev tshwm sim ntawm qhov txhaum nrog nws, nws yuav hais tias kuv twb tsis tau hais kom nws
hais txog cov txhaum, tab sis yuav twb qhia kuv. nws yog heev nyuaj uas yuav tau txiav qhov torrent ntawm
infomation uas nws muab.

Nyob hauv ntau daim ntawm infomation tias koj Bailiff tsim yog tias nws ib zaug siv
plaub lub hlis nyob rau hauv gaol nyob rau hauv ACT thiab nws pom "tsis txhaum los ntawm yog vim li cas ntawm impaiïment".

Nws hais tias thaum lub sij hawm ntawm qhov txhaum nyob rau hauv Tshiab South Wales nws yog nyob rau hauv Sydney rau rau lub hlis
nyob rau ntawm qhov chaw nyob ntawm nws niam thiab nws tus khub tam sim no.

Koj Baíhff qhia kuv hais tias nws tam sim no nyob rau ntawm Mathais Talbot Hostel thiab lawm
muaj txij li thaum nyob rau hauv 2013.

Thaum nug yog hais tias nws puas tau muaj them nyiaj ua hauj lwm rau nws teb, "Yog vim li cas lawm kuv tau them
kev ua hauj lwm thaum twg Kuv yog ib tug ntse, ib savant? "Nws thov hais tias nws Kuv muaj peev xwm los tsim ib tug LEEJ TWG THIAJ
Precedent; nws kuj tau muab ib tug lengthy thiab garbled tus account ntawm ib zaj dab neeg txog lub Pope. Nws
hais nyob rau ntawm ntev txog nws yav tas los kev cai lij choj teeb meem thiab txob txwm tiv thaiv uas nws twb

ntse siv.

Noj qab haus huv

Thaum nug txog nws kev noj qab nyob, koj Bailift `teb hais tias nws noj qab haus huv yog ñne. Nws tsis pom zoo siv
haus dej cawv los yog noj tej yam tshuaj noj thiab hais tias nws impaired raws li ib tug tau ofthe lub tsheb huam yuaj.

Mental Health

Raws li tawm Summary los ntawm None ntawm Wales Tsev Kho Mob Kev Puas Hlwb
Qhov kev pab cuam, hom qub 15 Lub kaum hli ntuj 2012, nyob rau hauv relation mus rau ib qho kev nkag tau mus kawm los ntawm 4-9 Lub kaum hli ntuj 2012, lub
neeg twb kuaj nrog situational Crisis thiab nrhiav lub hlwb raug mob. 0n tawm nws
medicated on ib milligram ntawm Risperidone. Nws piav raws li muaj nrhiav lub hlwb
kev raug mob thiab ib tug resultant hypo manic lub xeev thiab nws nthuav mus rau lub tsev kho mob nrog cov tub ceev xwm tom qab
contemplating tua tus kheej los ntawm dhia tawm sib txawv. Nws hu ua tub ceev xwm nws tus kheej thiab thov
txo lub hlwb kev pab. Suicidal ideation yeej thib ob mus rau ntau psychosocial stressors. Nws
tsis kam muab tej yam suicidal idcation thaum lub sij hawm ntawm tawm thiab muaj tsis muaj pov thawj ntawm mob
loj Mood teeb meem no los yog psychotic mob ntawm tawm. Nws pauv rov qab nyob hauv tsev thiab
mus ncig los ntawm tsheb ciav hlau mus rau Canberra. Nws pom zoo kom hais tias nws yuav tsum tau ua raws li nrog
Zej Zog Kev Puas Hlwb Kev Pab nyob rau hauv Canberra.

Ib daim ntawv qhia los ntawm Dr Stephen Allnutt, hom qub 10 lub Plaub Hlis Ntuj 2012, qhia tau tias tus neeg twb soj ntsuam
Whilst raug kaw nyob rau hauv lub AMC (tej zaum lub Alexander Maconoehie Centre, ib tug correctional
lub chaw nyob rau hauv ACT). Dr Allnutt qhia txog neeg raws li hais lus sai heev nrog khov,
manifesting suppressive hais lus, ua overly talkative, tshaj cov, expansive nyob rau hauv nws muaj kev cuam tshuam
thiab manifesting ib tug ib txwm rau perseveratien, thiab sib ntaus ntawm cov tswv yim. Nws manifested
nyuaj nyob rau hauv inhibiting nws qhov pib urgency thiab pom zoo ib tug xov tooj ntawm cov tsos mob uas
ciali yuav muaj raws li hypo mania. Dr Allnutt xeev tias neeg manifests ib tug loj heev
peev xwm nyob rau hauv nws puas muaj peev xwm mus hloov nws tus cwj pwm mus rau kev sib raug zoo kev cai. Dr Allnutt
concludes hais tias nyob rau hauv relation mus rau tag nrho cov txhaum uas twb lub Subj ect ntawm hais tias tsab ntawv ceeb toom, cov neeg
yuav tau raug kev txom nyem ib tug puas siab puas ntsws puas raws li ib tug rau txim ntawm lub hlwb puas tsuaj. Dr
Allnutt mus rau lub hais tias nws yog ib qhov tsis zoo li ntawd nws puas siab puas ntsws puas tiag impaired nws
muaj peev xwm paub txog qhov zoo thiab ntawm nws coj los yog hais tias nws nyob rau hauv nws compromised
muaj peev xwm paub hais tias nws cwj pwm mas tsis ncaj ncees lawm; txawm li cas los, thaum lub sij hawm lub sij hawm ntawm nws offending nws
puas siab puas ntsws puas muaj kev uas nws muaj peev xwm los tswj nws coj Kuv seriousl) r
compromised thiab on tshuav nyiaj npaum li nws muaj muaj nws ib tug tiv thaiv koj ntawm kev puas hlwb puas.

Ib co lus ceeb toom los ntawm Dr GJ George, pab tswv yim rau psychiatrist Forensic kev pab nyob rau hauv Mental
Kev noj qab nyob ACT, yeej muaj rau kuv. Qhia hom qub 29 lub Plaub Hlis Ntuj 2011, lub xeev uas koj Bailiff yog
unfît rau plead thiab yuav nyob twj ywm unfit indeñnitely vim hais tias nws muaj ib tug ntev kev puas hlwb xiam
los ntawm ib qho kev nrhiav organic puas siab puas ntsws teeb meem no hais txog ib tug lub hlwb raug mob. Nws qhib pib ntau ntawm
lub sij hawm nyob rau hauv ib tug ntev manic lub xeev thiab tshwm mus rau txom nyem los ntawm signiñcant Mood teeb meem no. Nws yog
heev distracted, me ntsis fatuous nyob rau hauv nws Mood thiab raug impulsive thiab disinhìbìted
tus cwj pwm. Nws muaj mob tshwm yuav ntev.

Ib daim ntawv qhia los ntawm Dr Leonard Lambeth thiab MS Natasha Shott los ntawm Forensic kev pab, Mental
Kev noj qab nyob ACT, hom qub 20 May 2009, qhia tias tus neeg nthuav raws li kev txom nyem ib organic
puas siab puas ntsws teeb meem no nrog lawn cov coob frontal cov tsos mob resulting nyob rau hauv ib tug neeg organic
teeb meem no. Qhia xaus lus tias koj Bailiff mas unfit rau plead vim xiam mus rau
nws puas siab puas ntsws kev. Nws tus cwj pwm tsis suav hais tias yog yuav modiñable los ntawm tej yam rau hauv daim ntawv ntawm
psychotherapy thiab tsuas yog txoj kev yuav tshuaj noj, tab sis nws tsis zoo li yog rnost
yuav raws txoj cai nrog rau kev noj tshuaj. Yog li ntawd, ib tug txo lub hlwb txoj kev kho mob kom yeej pom zoo,
raws li zoo raws li kev noj tshuaj nrog ib Depot kev noj tshuaj xws li Rìsperdal Consta thiab tshuaj ntawm

Mood stabilìsìng tshuaj noj (tab sis no tej zaum yuav tsis beneñciaî vim nws uas tsis yog-
raws kev cai).

Lwm yam qhia tau hais zoo xws li xaus.

Nyob rau hauv kuv lub tswv yim koj Baiìiff yuav kuaj nrog 294,11 loj Nenrocognitive teeb meem no Vim
mus Traumatic paj hlwb raug mob (tshawb nrhiav thiab Statistical Phau Ntawv ntawm Teebmeem Kev Xav mob-
Tsab, American txo lub hlwb Association, 2013). Nws txom nyem ib tug traumatic lub hlwb raug mob
uas tau nyob rau hauv nyuab nyob rau hauv thawj ntawm complex mloog, thawj lub peev xwm, kev kawm,
nco, ceev ntawm kev, thiab nyob rau hauv kev sib raug zoo disturbances Cognition. Nws tso pom disturbances
nyob rau hauv txoj kev xav Function (yooj yim ntxhov siab, affective labílity), thiab neeg hloov
(Dìsinhibition, suspiciousness).

Kaufman Briei `txawj ntse Xeem Ob Edition

Lub Kaufman nyuag txawj ntse Xeem Ob Edition yog ib tug luv luv, tus kheej muab
ntsuas ntawm lus thiab uas tsis yog-lus txawj ntse, thiab yuav siv tau rau cov me nyuam, cov me nyuam hluas thiab
cov laus ib ncua ntawm 4 mus rau 90 xyoos. Cov kev xeem loo peb cov qhab nia, lus, Nonverbal thiab IQ
Cuam tshuam qhab-nees. Cov lus muaj xws li cov qhab-nees tshwm sim nyob rau ob lub sub-xeem, lus Paub thiab
Riddles, thiab assesses lus, lub tsev kawm ntawv «reiated cov kev txawj los ntawm ib tug neeg soj ntsuam tus neeg lo lus paub,
ntau ntawm cov lus qhia dav dav, lus tswvyim tsim thiab yam kev muaj peev xwm. Lub Nonverbal
qhab-nees (qhov Matrices subtest) ntsuas muaj peev xwm daws tau tej teeb meem tshiab los ntawm ib qho kev soj ntsuam
tus neeg ntawd muaj peev xwm mus rau perceive kev sib raug zoo thiab ua kom tiav yeeb yam analogies (li Kaufman thiab
NL Kaufman, (1997) Kaufman nyuag txawj ntse Xeem Ob Edition Phau Ntawv, Pearson,
Minneapolis MN).

Koj Bailiff tau cov nram qab no tshwm sim uas yog qhia txog ntawm lub 90 rau ib theem ntawm xees
ntseeg siab:

S ntseeg siab feem pua
core caij nyoog Rank

Lus 80 74 88 9

Nonverbal 100 92 - 103 50

IQ cuam tshuam
Standard qhab nees 89 84 95 23 Kuv

Cov ïesults qhia tias tag nrho koj Bailiff functions nyob rau hauv pab pawg ntawm 10W nruab nrab
txawj ntse. Muaj ib qho tseem ceeb sib txawv ntawm nws lus thiab cov neeg uas tsis »lus tus qauv
cov qhab nia nrog nws lus qhab nees ua nyob rau hauv lub qis kawg ntawm tus thaj tsam ntawm tsawg txawj ntse thiab nws
uas tsis yog ~ verbai qhab nees ua qhov nruab nrab. Lub KBIT ~ 2 yog ib qho untimed kev xeem no, thiab koj Bailiff xav muaj
tau txais ntau tsawg tshwm sim yog hais tias ib tug timed xeem ntawm inteìiigence tau muab, vim hais tias nws
cov lus teb Puas heev qeeb thiab iaboured.

Thaum lub sij hawm xeem ntawv, thaum koj Bailiff pib tsis Muaj ib txhia ntawm tej yam khoom, nws Veered tawm nrog rua
tangential yam xws li nws blog, thiab kev cai lij choj precedent hais tias nws thov kom tau raug teeb tsa nyob rau hauv ib tug
cov ntaub ntawv nyob rau hauv uas nws tau muab kev koom tes nyob rau hauv ACT. Nws kuj reasoned nrov nrov thiab koom nyob rau hauv fatuous
luag uas yog lub yuav tsis muaj feem xyuam rau tej qhov pab ua hauj lwm nyob rau hauv qhov kev xeem qhov chaw. Qhov no hom
distracted tus cwj pwm ua ntau pom meej raws li cov lus nug no ua nyuaj. Nws kuj
tswv yim on nws tus kheej nthuav qhia hais tias nws mus yuav ib tug "qus twv" thiab hais tias
nws "ñippantly hais tias tej yam uas nws shouìdn't hais". Yog li ntawd, nws hais tias kom ib co degree koj

Bailiff siv cov distraction ntawm tangential cov dab neeg thiab lus kom npog thiab divert mloog
los ntawm nws kev txwv nyob rau hauv yam.

Ib sim twb tau mus nce saib pom mus rau hauv koj Baiiiff 's difticulties nrog coj tus cwj pwm, tab sis
nws khaw cia hais tias nws twb tsis xws difticulties, thiab tsis muab kev koom tes nrog rau teb
cov lus nug.

Qoj yuav tau sim

Kuv npaj canvass lub Presser cov txheej xwm nrog koj Bailiff. Nws muaj peev xwm qhia rau kuv tus nqi
tawm tsam hirn nyob rau hauv ACT thiab NSW. Nws tau hais tias nws yuav tsis tsum uas nkag mus rau ib tug plea vim
lub "precedent" ntawm tsis txhaum los ntawm yog vim li cas ntawm xiam nyob rau hauv ACT. Nws tsis teb
cov lus nug hais txog cov pawg neeg pab txiav txim los yog nyuaj tus pawg neeg pab txiav txim, thiab hais nyob rau hauv ntev txog tangential topics
xws li nws blog. Nws tau hais nyob rau hauv lus teb rau ib lo lus nug hais tias nws mloog ncua mas tine thiab nws
twb tsis muaj teeb meem nram qab no yog dab tsi tshwm sim nyob rau hauv lub tsev hais plaub. Thaum nug txog qhov teeb meem cia nws
ntuas paub dab tsi nws version ofthe qhov tseeb yog, nws muab ib tug garbled version ntawm nws tiv thaiv koj ua
tias tsis muaj ib tug keeb ntawm kev txhaum.

Koj Bailiff tsis teb nyob rau hauv tej yam muaj nuj nqis xom lees mus rau ntau cov lus nug hais txog cov Presser
cov txheej xwm, thiab yog li ntawd kuv tsis tau ua rau ib tug txiav txim siab raws li seb nyob rau hauv kuv lub tswv yim nws yog los
yuav sim. Kuv nco ntsoov lub yav tas los lus ceeb toom los ntawm Dr George thiab lwm tus neeg qhov chaw cìient tau
soj ntsuam raws li ua unfit, tab sis kuv yuav tsis tuaj txog rau ntawm ib tug ntshiab xaus raws ntawm no
tam sim no kev soj ntsuam.

Summary thiab lub tswv yim

Mob ntawm tej yam kev puas hlwb, kev mob los yog kev loj hlob disabili @ hais tias koj Bailiff
sujjfers los ntawm tam sim no thiab thaum lub sij hawm ofthe liam oßence on 11 Marck 2013

Koj Bailiff suffers los ntawm kev puas hlwb los ntawm 294,11 loj Neurocognitive teeb meem no Vim
Traumatic paj hlwb raug mob uas arose raws li ib tug ntawm ib lub tsheb huam yuaj thaum nws hnub nyoog 15.
Vim hais tias qhov kev raug mob thaum lub sij hawm arose ldie kev loj hlob lub sij hawm ua ntej mus rau lub hnub nyoog ntawm 18 xyoo, qhov no yuav
kev raws li ib txoj kev loj hlob xiam oob khab. Nws muaj deficits thiab nyuab nyob rau hauv cov nram qab no
peev xwm thawj:

l complex mloog (eg. pab mloog, Xaiv mloog, kev ceev)

0 Executive Function (eg. deficits nyob rau hauv kev npaj, kev txiav txim siab, ïesponding mus

tswv yim, disinhibition, puas siab puas ntsws ua yooj yim)

0 Kev Kawm thiab nco - nws pre-morbid txawj ntse mas tej zaum siab tshaj nws
tam sim no tsawg qhov nruab nrab nyob rau theem ntawm hauj lwm; nws muaj teeb meem nrog rau txoj lus xaiv on
caij nyoog nyob rau hauv thiab impairments nco

n Social Cognition (eg. tus cwj pwm kom meej tawm ntawm kev sib raug zoo tau ntau,
insensitivity mus rau kev sib raug zoo ntawm cov kev cai ntawm tus kheej kev nthuav qhia thiab sib tham, ntau
tsom ntsiab lus, neeg pluag kev txiav txim siab, me ntsis saib pom)

Nyob rau hauv kev hwm 0f tej yam mob ua, cov ntsiab lus ntawm koj BaiIWs tam sim no tsoom fwv txoj kev kho mob

(Ifmly)

Koj Bailiff tshwm t0 yuav tau txais cov tsis muaj kev kho mob tam sim no.

Tswv yim pom zoo rau tej kev kho mob rau yav tom ntej tsoom fwv los yog kev them nyiaj yug lub hom phiaj, nrog rau ib qho
lub tswv yim on seb tus thov kev kho mob yog muaj nyob rau hauv kev puas hlwb noj qab haus huv los yog chaw
los ntawm mental health kev pab nyob rau hauv NSW los yog ACT

Kuv xav kom koj Bailifî `raug soj ntsuam los ntawm ib tug kws neurologist nyob rau hauv lub Íield ntawm lub sij hawm ntev
zoo thiab ua tau Rehabilitation rau traumatic lub hlwb raug mob, nrog rau cov neeg tau ntawm
noj tshuaj los mus pab nyob rau hauv kev tswj cov neeg tus cwj pwm. Tej zaum yuav muaj cov kev pab cuam nyob rau hauv
thawj ntawm kev sib raug zoo thiab interpersonal kev txawj uas yuav pab nws kom zoo dua tswj nws
tus cwj pwm deficits thiab nyuab. Nws yog ib doubtful seb txoj kev kho mob yuav muaj nyob rau hauv
puas siab puas ntsws noj qab haus huv nyob rau hauv cov chaw NSW los yog ACT. Qhov loj qhov teeb meem nyob rau hauv kev tiv thaiv ntxiv offending
tus cwj pwm yog qhov koj Bailiffs problematic nyuaj tus cwj pwm, thiab nws nkawd hais tias nws
yuav tsis ua raws li tej Nrog prescribed noj tshuaj; yog li ntawd xwb avaiiable hauv chav kawm ntawv qhov kev txiav txim
yuav ib txoj kev kho mob kom thiaj ua tau rau kev noj tshuaj thiab / los yog muaj kev koom tes nyob rau hauv ib qho kev coj cwj pwm
moditication Rehabilitation kev pab yog hais tias muaj ib tug muaj txoj kev pab.

Kev pom zoo nyob rau degree ntawm kev saib xyuas los yog saib xyuas yuav tsum tau tej yam luider

thov txoj kev kho mob tsoom fwv 0r kev them nyiaj yug lub hom phiaj thiab kev saib xyuas ofsuch
tsis pub dhau NSW los yog ACT

Koj Bailiff yuav muaj txiaj ntsim los ntawm kev saib xyuas thiab nyob ze Kev them nyiaj yug, tab sis nws yog ib qhov tsis zoo li hais tias nws
yuav muab kev koom tes nrog tej yam kev kho mob tsoom fwv los yog kev them nyiaj yug lub hom phiaj.

Qoj t0 yuav sim 1m der lub txheej xwm Presser

Kuv yeej tsis tau kos ib tug xaus txog c1ient tus muaj peev xwm mus rau lub tsev hais plaub txoj kev comprehend
raws li txiav txim los ntawm lub Presser cov txheej xwm tshuav nqi rau nws tsis muaj cov lus teb cov lus nug no nug.
Nyob rau hauv cov txheej xwm Kesavarajah nws yog ib qhov tsis zoo li hais tias nws muaj peev xwm ceev cia mloog los ntawm cov hoob kawm ntawm
lub tsev hais plaub Hais Plaub thiab nws disinhibited thiab intrusive social tus cwj pwm yuav

problematic.

Ua tsaug rau koj nug kuv mus ntsuam xyuas cov neeg no.

Susan Hayes

14 Lub rau hli ntuj 2013...